← All guides Business Owners · Retirement & Benefits

Have employees? CalSavers vs. SIMPLE IRA vs. 401(k)

7 min read
Educational only

This guide is for general education and is not personalized investment advice. Your situation is unique. Consider talking with a qualified professional before making financial decisions.

If you own a California business with even one W-2 employee, state law says you have to do something about retirement savings. The good news: you get to choose what. This guide explains what the CalSavers requirement actually asks of you, how the three most common routes work side by side, and the questions to ask before you sign up for anything.

Just you, no employees? This guide isn't for you yet. Read SEP IRA vs. Solo 401(k) instead.

wait, is this required?

What California actually requires

California's retirement savings law now covers employers with at least one employee (other than the owners). The last group, employers with one to four employees, had a registration deadline of December 31, 2025 (CalSavers, 2026). If you hire your first employee now, the requirement applies to you too.

The rule itself is simple. You have two ways to comply:

  1. 1
    Register for CalSaversThe state-run program. You facilitate it through payroll; you don't run it.
  2. 2
    Offer a qualified plan and certify your exemptionFor example, a SIMPLE IRA or a 401(k). Then tell CalSavers you're exempt.

The step that's easy to skip: if you already offer a plan, certify your exemption with CalSavers so the state knows (and the compliance notices stop).

Doing neither can lead to penalties per eligible employee once the state has sent you notice. Check calsavers.com for the current penalty schedule and your status. Other exemptions exist too (for example, government, religious, and tribal employers), and CalSavers can confirm whether one fits you.


the three common routes

Your three main options at a glance

There are other plan types, but these are three common routes for small California employers. Tap any box for the details.


option 1

CalSavers: the state-run option

CalSavers is California's own retirement savings program. Each employee gets their own Roth IRA in their name, funded by payroll deductions. It's portable, so it goes with them when they leave.

How it works

  • Your job: register, add your employees' information, and send their contributions through payroll. That's about it.
  • Their side: eligible employees (18 and older) are enrolled automatically at 5% of pay unless they opt out or pick another rate. Unless they change it, the rate generally goes up 1% a year, up to 8% (CalSavers, 2026; California EDD, 2026).
  • Limits: because these are IRAs, IRA limits apply: $7,500 for 2026, plus a $1,100 catch-up at 50 and up, across all of the employee's IRAs combined.

What to watch for

  • No employer contributions. You aren't allowed to contribute or match. If attracting and keeping people with a match matters to you, this route can't do it.
  • You can't advise. Employers aren't supposed to tell employees whether to join, how much to save, or how to invest. Point questions to CalSavers.
  • Roth means after-tax. Contributions don't lower your employees' taxable pay today. CalSavers explains the account choices to them directly.

option 2

SIMPLE IRA: the middle ground

A SIMPLE IRA (Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees) is an IRA-based plan for businesses with, generally, 100 or fewer employees. Employees save from their paychecks, and you're required to put something in too.

How it works

  • Employee limit for 2026: $17,000, plus a $4,000 catch-up at 50 and up, or $5,250 at ages 60 to 63. Plans at employers with 25 or fewer employees, and some larger employers that elect it, use different, higher deferral limits (IRS Notice 2025-67). Ask your provider which limits apply to your plan.
  • Your required contribution, chosen each year: either a 2% nonelective contribution for every eligible employee (whether or not they save) or a dollar-for-dollar match up to 3% of pay. The match can be lowered, but not below 1%, and only in limited years.
  • Vesting: everything, including your contributions, belongs to the employee right away.
  • Timing: in general, a new SIMPLE IRA has to be set up by October 1 to start that year. Brand-new businesses that start after October 1 can set one up as soon as it's administratively feasible.

What to watch for

  • It generally has to be your only plan. You can't run a SIMPLE IRA alongside a 401(k) for the same year.
  • The contribution isn't optional. Once you pick the 2% or the match for a year, it's a real cost to budget for.
  • Early withdrawals cost more at first. Withdrawals in the first two years of participation can face a 25% additional tax instead of the usual 10% (IRS, 2026). Worth explaining to your team.

option 3

401(k): the most flexible

A 401(k) is the plan many people know from larger employers, and it's available to businesses of any size. Employees can save up to $24,500 for 2026, with an $8,000 catch-up at 50 and up, and $11,250 instead at ages 60 to 63 (IRS Notice 2025-67).

How it works

  • You design it. Whether you contribute, how much, a vesting schedule, Roth options, loans: these are choices, within IRS rules.
  • Traditional design: employer contributions can be flexible, but the plan generally has to pass yearly nondiscrimination tests that make sure it doesn't favor owners and higher earners. If it fails, owners and other higher earners may have contributions returned.
  • "Safe harbor" design: you commit to a set employer contribution (a required match or nonelective contribution that employees own right away), and in exchange the plan can skip certain of those yearly tests. Owners sometimes choose this so they can save more predictably, in exchange for the required contribution.
  • Automatic enrollment: under SECURE 2.0, many 401(k) plans set up after 2022 generally have to enroll employees automatically, with exceptions for new and very small businesses. Ask your provider how this applies to you.

What to watch for

  • More paperwork and cost. Expect setup and ongoing fees, an annual Form 5500 filing in general, and testing if you're not safe harbor.
  • You take on fiduciary duties. As the plan sponsor, you're generally responsible for choosing and monitoring the provider, the fees, and the investment menu. Some providers share part of that responsibility in writing; ask exactly which part.
  • Tax credits may help. SECURE 2.0 created and expanded tax credits for small employers that start a plan, add automatic enrollment, or make employer contributions. Eligibility and amounts depend on your business, so confirm the details at IRS.gov (Form 8881) or with a tax professional.

side by side

The quick comparison (2026)

FeatureCalSaversSIMPLE IRA401(k)
Who runs itThe State of CaliforniaYou, through a providerYou, through a provider
Employee limitIRA limit: $7,500 ($1,100 catch-up at 50+)$17,000 ($4,000 catch-up at 50+; $5,250 at 60 to 63); higher for some$24,500 ($8,000 at 50+; $11,250 at 60 to 63)
Employer moneyNot allowedRequired: 2% for all, or match up to 3%Optional, or required set amount if safe harbor
Roth optionRoth IRA is the defaultDepends on the providerIf the plan offers it
Your adminLow: roster and payrollLow to moderateHighest: fees, testing, Form 5500
Cost to the businessNo employer feeYour contributions plus provider feesContributions (if any), setup and ongoing fees
Other plans allowed?Offer a qualified plan instead and you're exempt (certify it)Generally must be your only planCan be paired with other designs
Setup timingRegister when requiredGenerally by October 1 for a new planVaries; ask your provider

None of these is best for everyone. CalSavers keeps your workload low, a SIMPLE IRA adds an employer contribution with modest paperwork, and a 401(k) gives you the most room to design something, in exchange for the most responsibility. All limits are 2026 figures and general only; confirm at IRS.gov or with a tax professional.


before you sign anything

Questions to ask any provider

If you're looking at a SIMPLE IRA or a 401(k), ask every provider the same questions so the answers line up:

  1. "What does this cost, in total?" Setup, yearly, per-participant, and fund expenses. Ask for it in dollars, in writing.
  2. "Who pays which fees: the business or the employees?"
  3. "What work stays with me?" Payroll uploads, eligibility tracking, notices, Form 5500, testing.
  4. "Do you connect directly to my payroll system?"
  5. "What fiduciary responsibility do you take on, in writing, and what stays with me?"
  6. "What's on the investment menu, and who chose it?"
  7. "Does the plan offer Roth contributions and loans?"
  8. "How do you help me certify my CalSavers exemption?"
  9. "What happens, and what does it cost, if I switch providers later?"
  10. "How are you compensated?" And, if they'll advise on the plan: "Will you act as a fiduciary for this advice at all times?"

Also worth a call with your tax professional: which plan fits your business structure, and whether any startup credits apply.

the most important part

Doing nothing isn't one of the options

If you have employees in California, you need either CalSavers or a qualified plan. The real choice is how much you want to contribute and how much you want to manage.

  • Want the lightest lift? CalSavers is built for that, but you can't add money for your team.
  • Want to contribute without much admin? That's the SIMPLE IRA's lane. Mind the October 1 setup date.
  • Want the most flexibility? A 401(k) offers it, with more cost and responsibility.
  • Already have a plan? Make sure you've certified your exemption with CalSavers.

Sources: CalSavers, "Facilitating CalSavers" and "Frequently Asked Questions" (calsavers.com, 2026); California State Treasurer, CalSavers Retirement Savings Board (treasurer.ca.gov). IRS, "SIMPLE IRA plan" (irs.gov, 2026). IRS Notice 2025-67, 2026 retirement plan limits (irs.gov, 2025). IRS Publication 560, "Retirement Plans for Small Business" (irs.gov, 2025). IRS, Instructions for Form 8881 (Rev. December 2025) (irs.gov). California Employment Development Department, "CalSavers" (edd.ca.gov, 2026). Contribution limits and tax rules shown are for 2026 and general only; confirm at IRS.gov or with a tax professional.