Six big brokerages, side by side
This guide is for general education and is not personalized investment advice. Your situation is unique. Consider talking with a qualified professional before making financial decisions.
When you tap buy, what happens next depends partly on the firm holding your account: where it sends your order, what it does with your spare cash, and what it charges. Here are six of the largest U.S. brokerages in one chart, using each firm's own published numbers, plus what each row means and how to check it yourself.
This is not a ranking or a recommendation. Firms are listed alphabetically. I'm not paid by any of them for this page.
Why I won't name a favorite here: as an investment adviser, I can't recommend a specific brokerage publicly. What I can do is lay out six of the largest side by side, using their own numbers, so you have what you need to compare them yourself. If you'd like help deciding which one fits your situation, that's a conversation we can have one on one.
Every number comes from the firm's own website or regulatory filings, checked on the dates shown. Prices, rates and policies change often, so confirm anything that matters to you on the firm's site before you act.
why these six?
How I picked them
I didn't pick favorites. I used one rule: the largest U.S. firms for self-directed investors, ranked by the client assets each one reports for the narrowest part of its business that includes self-directed brokerage, from its most recent filing or official release:
- Fidelity: $19.9 trillion in assets under administration (June 30, 2026)
- Charles Schwab: $13.3 trillion in client assets (Sept. 30, 2026)
- Vanguard: $11.9 trillion in assets under management (Mar. 31, 2026)
- E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley: $1.8 trillion in self-directed client assets (Sept. 30, 2026)
- Interactive Brokers: $965 billion in customer equity (Sept. 30, 2026)
- Merrill Edge: $664 billion in Bank of America consumer investment assets (Sept. 30, 2026)
Next in line was Robinhood ($396 billion in platform assets, Sept. 30, 2026). Two honest caveats: Fidelity, Schwab and Vanguard only publish firm-wide totals, which include workplace plans and institutional business, and each firm measures assets a little differently. J.P. Morgan doesn't publish a self-directed figure separate from its private bank, so I left it out rather than guess. Size is just how I chose which firms to show. It says nothing about which one fits you.
the big chart
The comparison
On a phone, swipe the chart sideways. The row names stay pinned on the left.
| Checked Nov. 9, 2026 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trading costs | ||||||
| Online U.S. stock & ETF commission | $0Broker-assisted: $25 | $0OTC stocks: $6.95 | $0 | $0 on IBKR LiteIBKR Pro: $0.0005 to $0.005 per share, $0.35 to $1 minimum | $0Broker-assisted: $29.95 | $0Broker-assisted: $25 (under $1M in qualifying assets) |
| Options, per contract | $0.65 | $0.65$0.50 with 30+ trades a quarter | $0.65$0 to buy to close at $0.65 or less | Up to $0.65$1 minimum per order | $0.65 | $1.00Under $1M in qualifying assets |
| Minimum to open a brokerage account | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 (cash account) | $0 | $0Individual funds have their own minimums |
| Where your order goes (Rule 606 reports, Q3 2026) | ||||||
| Payment for order flow on stock orders | Yes | Yes, on self-directed orders | Yes | IBKR Lite: yesIBKR Pro: no | NoPer its report | No |
| Payment for order flow on options orders | Yes | Yes, on self-directed orders | Yes | None stated in its report | Not stated in its report | No |
| Top 2 destinations for S&P 500 market orders | Citadel Securities (about 40%), Virtu Americas (about 20%) | Morgan Stanley & Co., an affiliate (about 40%), Citadel Securities (about 21%) | CrossStream ATS (22%), Citadel Securities (20%)September | Nasdaq (about 37%), Cboe EDGX (about 21%)All non-directed orders; few were market orders | BofA Securities, an affiliate (about 49%), Level Markets (about 31%) | Citadel Securities (33%), G1 Execution (23%)July |
| Your uninvested cash | ||||||
| Where cash goes by default | Bank sweep for most accountsRate shown after login | Bank sweep (Bank Deposit Program) | Money market fund (for new retail accounts) | Interest paid on the cash balance at IBKRTiered; conditions apply. Insured bank sweep is opt-in | Bank sweep (Merrill Lynch Bank Deposit Program) | Money market fund |
| Moving and protection | ||||||
| Fee to transfer your whole account out | $50Partial transfers: $0 | $75 | $0 | None | $49.95 | $100Waived at $5M+ in qualifying assets |
| SIPC member | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Coverage beyond SIPC | Lloyd's of London, $600M firm-wide | $1B firm-wide; $1.9M cash per client | $1B firm-wide; $1.9M cash per account | Lloyd's of London, up to $30M more per account ($900K cash), $150M firm-wide | Lloyd's of London, $1B firm-wide; $1.9M cash per customer | Additional coverage through an insurerLimits not stated on the pages checked |
| Features | ||||||
| Fractional shares | Stocks and ETFs (7,000+), from $1 | Pilot, starting with S&P 100 stocks, $5 minimum | Stocks and ETFs, from $1 | Yes | Not listed on the pages checked | Vanguard ETFs, from $1 |
| Overnight trading | Yes, 24/5 on thinkorswim1,300+ stocks and ETFs | Yes, Sun. to Thu., 8 p.m. to 4 a.m. ET | Not listed on the pages checked | Yes, 8 p.m. to 3:50 a.m. ET | Not listed on the pages checked | Not listed on the pages checked |
| IRA / Roth IRA / custodial / HSA | Yes / Yes / Yes / HSA only as a brokerage window inside another provider's HSA | Yes / Yes / Yes / HSA not listed | Yes / Yes / Yes / Yes | Yes / Yes / Yes (UGMA/UTMA) / HSA not listed | Yes / Yes / Yes / HSA not listed | Yes / Yes / Yes / HSA not listed |
| Fee to buy a mutual fund outside the no-fee list | Up to $74.95$0 to sell | Not listed on the pages checked | $49.95, some up to $100$0 to sell | Not listed on the pages checked | $19.95 online | $20 onlineUnder $1M in qualifying assets |
| Who owns it | ||||||
| Parent company | The Charles Schwab Corporation (public: SCHW) | Morgan Stanley (public: MS) | FMR LLC (privately held) | Interactive Brokers Group (public: IBKR) | Bank of America (public: BAC) | Owned by its funds, which are owned by their shareholders (not publicly traded) |
Firms are listed alphabetically. Logos are each firm's own app icon, shown for recognition only, with no affiliation or endorsement. Percentages are rounded shares of S&P 500 market orders in each firm's Q3 2026 Rule 606 report (monthly figures; the month is noted where only one was available). "Not listed on the pages checked" means I couldn't confirm it from the firm's own site, not that the firm doesn't offer it. Fees are standard published rates for self-directed online accounts; discounts and other fees may apply.
what am I looking at?
What each row means
- Commission. The fee to buy or sell a U.S. stock or ETF online. "$0" doesn't mean the trade costs nothing; firms can earn money in other ways, like the rows below.
- Payment for order flow. Some trading firms (often called wholesalers) pay brokers to send them customer orders. Brokers that take it must still seek the best execution they reasonably can for you, and they publish where orders go every quarter in a Rule 606 report. Supporters say it helps fund $0 commissions; critics say it creates a conflict of interest. The SEC has studied both sides.
- Where orders went. The top destinations for market orders in the firm's most recent 606 report. This is the "where did my order go?" question from the video, answered from the source.
- Cash sweep. Where uninvested cash sits by default. A bank sweep and a money market fund work differently, can pay very different rates, and have different protections (FDIC insurance for bank deposits up to its limits; SIPC for securities, with limits). The default isn't always the only option.
- Transfer-out fee. What the firm charges to move your whole account to another firm (an ACAT transfer). Some firms you move to will reimburse this; ask.
- SIPC and excess coverage. SIPC protects customers if a brokerage firm fails and securities or cash are missing, up to $500,000 including a $250,000 limit for cash. It does not protect against investment losses. "Excess SIPC" is extra private insurance some firms buy, with its own limits.
- Fractional shares. Whether you can buy part of a share with a dollar amount. Details vary (which stocks, which account types).
what a chart can't show
What this chart leaves out
A table is good at prices and policies. It's not good at the things people often care about most once they've opened an account:
- Service. How easy it is to reach a person, and whether there's a local branch.
- The app itself. What feels clear to one person feels cluttered to another.
- Your situation. Which accounts you need, how you invest, and what you already have elsewhere.
- Execution quality. Whether a firm took payment for order flow doesn't tell you, by itself, the price you got. Firms publish execution statistics separately (Rule 605 reports), and they're hard to compare.
check it yourself
Five questions to ask any brokerage
- "Where did you route my stock orders last quarter, and do you receive payment for them?" (Ask for the Rule 606 report.)
- "Where does my uninvested cash go by default, what does it pay today, and what are my other options?"
- "What does it cost to transfer my account out?"
- "What protection applies to my cash and my securities, and what are the limits?"
- "Are there account fees I won't see on the pricing page (paper statements, wires, inactivity, broker-assisted trades)?"
You can also look up any firm's record for free on FINRA BrokerCheck (brokercheck.finra.org) and confirm SIPC membership at sipc.org.
If you're working with a financial professional, two more questions: "How are you compensated?" and "Will you act as a fiduciary for this advice at all times?"
the most important part
Keep it in perspective
There isn't one best brokerage. There's the one whose costs, cash handling and service fit how you actually invest.
- Read the fine print once. The cash sweep and transfer-out rows are the ones people most often never look at.
- Data ages. Use this chart as a starting list of questions, then confirm on the firm's own site.
Important information: Information comes from each firm's public website, Rule 606 reports and SEC filings, checked November 9, 2026, and may have changed since. Collin Sinnott and StratiCo receive no compensation from any firm on this page for this content. Firm names are trademarks of their owners and are used for identification only; no endorsement is implied. Firms were included only because of the size rule described above, which is not a measure of quality, and inclusion is not a recommendation of any firm, product or service. This page does not cover every fee, feature or firm. SIPC protection does not cover losses in market value. Current pricing does not predict future pricing.
Sources: Schwab pricing, Schwab Pricing Guide (Apr. 2026), Schwab 606 report, Q3 2026, Schwab Cash Features Disclosure (Oct. 2026), Schwab 10-Q, Q3 2026; E*TRADE pricing, E*TRADE order routing reports, E*TRADE fractional shares, E*TRADE extended hours, Morgan Stanley 10-Q, Q3 2026; Fidelity commissions, Fidelity pricing and fees, Fidelity 606 reports, Fidelity account protection FAQ, Fidelity Q2 2026 business update; IBKR stock commissions, IBKR options commissions, IBKR other fees, IBKR client protection, IBKR overnight trading, IBKR 606 report, Q3 2026, IBKR Q3 2026 release; Merrill Edge pricing, Merrill Edge fee schedule (Nov. 2025), Merrill 606 reports, Merrill Edge help and support, Bank of America Q3 2026 release; Vanguard fees and commissions (effective July 10, 2026), Vanguard 606 report, Q3 2026, Vanguard settlement fund, Vanguard Brokerage account agreement (Oct. 2026), Vanguard corporate (May 2026); Robinhood Q3 2026 release, SIPC, What SIPC Protects, FINRA Rule 5310 (best execution).